Cheer vs GitHub Advanced Security
GitHub’s security add-ons find things. Cheer decides what to do about them and keeps the record. Most teams that use Cheer keep the add-ons. This page is about where the difference shows up, and where it doesn’t.
What GitHub Advanced Security does that Cheer doesn’t
Two add-ons, billed per active committer: Secret Protection at $19 and Code Security at $30 a month. Push protection blocks a secret before it lands, and only something in GitHub’s push path can do that. CodeQL on private repos needs the Code Security licence. Cheer does neither, and doesn’t try to.
Where the differences show up in practice
Findings
GitHubRaises alerts per repo. What to do about each one is up to whoever opens the security tab.
CheerReads the same alerts, plus Sonar, Semgrep, CodeRabbit and your CI, against one policy, and returns cleared, noted or held with a sentence.
Dismissals
GitHubA dismissal is per alert, per repo, with a reason and no expiry. The same alert on another repo is a new decision.
CheerAn waiver has a name, a reason and an expiry, and carries across every future version. Nobody decides the same thing twice.
Fixes
GitHubCopilot Autofix and Dependabot open pull requests without building them. Whether the fix works is found out in review.
CheerThe refresh applies the upgrade, builds it, runs the tests and checks it against policy in a sandbox, then opens a PR only if it would pass.
Reach
GitHubSecurity overview works repo by repo, with campaigns to burn down alerts across an organisation.
CheerAsk what a package or an advisory reaches and get the list of components, what has already been done on each, and which ones haven’t been scanned.
The record
GitHubAlert history per repo. No record of what a version was checked against when it shipped.
CheerA manifest per version, stamped at every gate, written to the commit. It answers why a version shipped, months later.
Billing
GitHubPer active committer. On an AI-heavy repo every agent push is a committer. A 200-committer org pays about $118,000 a year for both add-ons.
CheerRuns, minutes and storage. People and components are never counted.
Side by side
CheerGitHub Advanced Security
Finding
Secret push protectionNoYes
CodeQL on private reposNeeds the licenceYes
Reads results from other scanners and reviewersYesPartly, via SARIF upload
Verifies a finding is reachable before raising itYesNo
Deciding
One policy across every sourceYesNo
Waiver with a name and an expiryYesDismissal, no expiry
Decision carries across versions and reposYesPer alert, per repo
Same rules for agent-written and human-written codeYesNo
Fixing
Fix PRs built and tested before they openYesNo
Reach across the estate for an advisoryYesPer repo, plus campaigns
The record
Manifest per version, stamped at each gateYesNo
Written to the commit, verifiable offlineYesNo
AI contribution counted per versionYesNo
Pricing
MeterRuns, minutes, storagePer active committer
Free tier100 runs a month, any repoPublic repos only
Paying per committer for scanning?
Keep the add-ons for push protection and CodeQL. Point Cheer at their output and keep the decisions and the record here. It takes about ten minutes.
$ cheer reach pkg:npm/undici
4 of 31 components27 don’t carry it
billing-ui waived until 30 Oct by R. ChenWaived
legacy-admin hasn’t been scannedNot scanned